Crumbles
diet series

The Crumbles journal

Vegan crumble: replacing butter without losing the crunch (fats, binders, toppings)

A crumble is almost vegan already. Only butter and dairy toppings stand in the way. We break down what butter does, and which plant-based fat fills each role.

A barista preparing a crumble in a glass jar at the Crumbles counter

Fruit, flour, sugar: a crumble is almost vegan by nature. Only butter and dairy toppings (custard, whipped cream) are a problem.

This is the plant-based take on our homemade apple crumble recipe, built “by function”: what butter does, and which substitute fills each role.

We then apply it to the four steps of composition: fruit, base, toppings and crumblings.

What butter really does in a crumble topping

Butter does several jobs at once; few substitutes do them all.

Two crumbles in jars on the wooden ledge of the Crumbles window
crumbs are an art

Rubbing in: coating flour to get crumbs, not dough

Fat coats the flour so you get coarse crumbs rather than smooth dough. Solid fats do this best.

Flavour and browning (Maillard, nutty notes)

Milk proteins brown in the oven. Compensate with brown sugar, ground almonds and a pinch of salt.

Why cold fat makes crunchier crumbs

Cold fat stays in small pieces that melt in the oven and leave tiny air pockets. Warm fat makes a dense slab.

What to replace butter with in a vegan crumble: the comparison

Four families of plant fats work. Ratios are starting points per 100 g of flour.

Block vegan butter / margarine

The closest substitute. Pick a baking block, not a watery spread.

Starting ratio
60–70 g per 100 g flour

Refined coconut oil

The crunchiest. Use it cold, grated or diced.

Starting ratio
50–55 g per 100 g flour

Liquid oils (rapeseed, mild olive)

Drizzle into the dry mix and rub between your palms. Use less.

Starting ratio
40–45 g per 100 g flour

Nut butters (almond, hazelnut, cashew)

Flavour and binding; pair with a little oil.

Starting ratio
35–40 g + 15 g oil per 100 g flour

Summary table: crunch, flavour, ease, cost, ratio per 100 g of flour

SubstituteCrunchFlavourEaseCostRatio / 100 g flour
Block vegan butterGoodNeutralVery easyModerate60–70 g
Refined coconut oilExcellentNeutralMediumHigher50–55 g
Rapeseed / mild olive oilFairNeutral / fruityEasyLow40–45 g

Start with block vegan butter, then mix families once you master the technique.

The basic vegan crumble topping: ratios and technique

A base for a medium dish, using block vegan butter.

For a medium dish

  • 150 g flour
  • 90–100 g cold block vegan butter
  • 70 g brown sugar
  • A pinch of salt

Technique

  1. Mix the dry ingredients

    Flour, sugar, salt.

  2. Rub in with fingertips

    Quickly, until coarse crumbs form.

  3. Chill 20 minutes

    The crumbs set and hold in the oven.

  4. Scatter without pressing

    Air between crumbs means crunch.

A Crumbles team member piping a topping into a crumble cup
technique first

For baking, follow our homemade apple crumble recipe; vegan topping browns a little slower, so judge by colour.

Varying the base: oats, ground almonds, wholemeal sugar, hazelnuts

Crumbles in jars topped with crushed pistachios and caramel
texture in the base

The base, step two of composition, makes up for the flavour butter no longer brings.

Oat flakes

More rustic crunch.

Ground almonds

Browns well.

Wholemeal sugar

Caramel notes.

Crumblings use the same topping, baked separately. See our guide Build your crumble for the four steps.

The fruit: nothing changes… almost

Most fruit works as is under a vegan topping.

For juicy fruit, bind the juice with a teaspoon of starch instead of butter.

In November, think autumn and winter fruit:

Apple

The safe bet.

Pear

Juicy: add starch.

Quince

Pre-cook longer.

See our article on seasonal fruit for the perfect crumble.

Vegan toppings: plant custard, coconut cream, butter-free caramel

Each dairy topping has a convincing plant-based twin.

Oat or soy milk custard thickened with starch (egg-free)

50 cl plant milk, 40–50 g sugar, 20 g cornflour, vanilla; thicken gently while whisking.

Coconut whipped cream: the chilled-can trick

Chill a can of full-fat coconut milk overnight, whip only the solid cream with icing sugar.

Coconut milk caramel

Dry caramel loosened with hot coconut milk and a pinch of salt.

Two dessert cups topped with whipped cream on a window ledge
whipped cream, coconut style

These fit the four-step logic of Build your crumble: the beginner’s guide.

Mistakes that make a vegan crumble soggy or greasy

Four common mistakes, all easy to fix.

Too much oil

Stick to 40–45 g per 100 g flour.

Warm fat

Everything straight from the fridge.

Undrained fruit

Drain and bind with starch.

Packed topping

Scatter, don’t press.

For more troubleshooting, read our 5 secrets of a perfect homemade crumble.

Vegan AND gluten-free crumble: is it possible?

Yes. The challenge becomes the flour: pick your gluten-free blend first, then replace the butter as above.

And at Crumbles?

At 3 rue Pierre Fontaine, everything is homemade, with organic Île-de-France flour and seasonal French fruit.

Some bases can be adapted depending on the day: ask at the counter for today’s options.

Four crumbles in jars at the orange window of Crumbles, a bike parked behind
rue Pierre Fontaine, Paris 9thHomemade, seasonal French fruit, organic Île-de-France flour.

A plant-milk latte pairs nicely; see which drink with a crumble.

Want a taste before trying it yourself? Come build your crumble on rue Pierre Fontaine (Paris 9th) and ask about today’s possible adaptations.

Frequently asked questions

FAQ

Is a crumble vegan?

Not classically: the topping uses butter and is often served with dairy custard. Everything else is plant-based.

What can replace butter in a crumble?

Block vegan butter (60–70 g per 100 g flour), refined coconut oil (50–55 g), liquid oil (40–45 g) or nut butters, always cold.

Can you make a crumble with olive oil?

Yes, with a mild olive oil at 40–45 g per 100 g of flour.

Does coconut oil taste of coconut?

Virgin coconut oil does; refined coconut oil is almost neutral.

How do you make vegan custard?

Heat oat or soy milk with sugar and vanilla, thicken with cornflour.

Can vegan crumble be frozen?

Yes; see our 5 secrets of a perfect homemade crumble for freezing and reheating.

Read also

Going further

For the starting base we adapt here, head back to our apple crumble recipe.

See the menuCall